
I know it sounds harsh and maybe even Nazi-esque, but sometimes you meet a book so bad that burning it is not only acceptable, but it is in fact your moral and ethical responsibility. Let me explain.
I have been out of town for an unholy amount of time this summer. As such Erica has been reading a lot of books including the pop-culture phenomenon Twilight by Stephenie Myer. After Erica read the first one she demanded I do the same. So as an obedient husband I agreed. It didn’t take me long to finish and as a story it had some parts that were interesting. Overall, however, I did not love the book.
One of my biggest complaints is Stephenie Myer’s new interpretation of vampires. Basically take all the things that make vampires supernatural and multiply them by 10. Meyer’s vampires are glamorous, rich, intelligent, blood-sucking gods. For good measure she includes an all too average heroine, the young, awkward teenager Bella. It’s not long before the hopelessly average and clumsy Bella has attracted the eye of the picturesque vampire Edward. It really is a tale as old as time: *spoiler*
Boy is vampire, boy wants to eat girl, girl is nerd, girl almost gets hit by a car and then almost gets raped, girl and hungry vampire fall in love. Then, girl almost gets eaten by another vampire. Vampire 1 (Edward) kills vampire 2 (random unimportant plot device whose name matters not) and vampire and girl go to prom. Just your standard vampire love story.
Now not to be mean or overly psychoanalytical but sometimes I had to wonder if our vampire hero Edward was not Mrs. Myer’s own fairy-tale version of love. He is beautiful beyond reason, intelligent, tortured and sensitive, inhumanly strong, and has a confident swagger that lets you know you never need to worry—or think—again. For added measure Edward can also read minds, has a perfect chiseled physique, has breath that serves as an irresistible pseudo date-rape drug and is a musical savant. I mean if your going to create you ideal love-interest why not go all out. Finally, as if everything else wasn’t attractive enough these vampires have no fear of the sun in fact it only serve to make them more enticing by causing their skin to sparkle like a sea of diamonds. How convenient.
Now if it stopped there maybe it would be ok. But Myer is not done yet. Yes she has created what some women may consider an ideal love interest. Yes she has rewritten the vampire myth to a point that Bram Stoker’s Dracula now really does look like a piece of classic Western literature and its story completely plausible. And yes she has given us a window into what may appear to be her—let’s call them interesting—sexual fantasies. But Myer really excels in making her vampire hero, Edward, completely creepy.
Top 3 reasons Edward is creepy.
3. Edward’s favorite nighttime activity is to watch Bella sleep. Oh that may sound sweet you say, but let’s put this in context. Edward comes into Bella’s room long before they are “dating”. He just loves the way she smells so much that he can’t stay away. Nothing says love like stalking you while nursing an almost uncontrollable to desire to drain your sleeping body of blood.
2. Did I mention that part of the attraction for Edward is the way Bella smells. No silly, not her hair or her perfume, her blood. Bella’s blood is an aromatic bouquet of yummy. On more than one occasion Edward almost eats her. And yes I realize that many women enjoy being desired, but I think this form of desire may be unhealthy if not deadly.
1. And our number one reason Edward is creepy *drum roll please* Edward is approx 80 years older than our heroine. Edward was turned into a vampire in the early twentieth century. (I could fact check this and give the specific year, but it would mean opening the book again and I’m afraid that the simply act of opening that book may steal a portion of my soul.) Did I mention Bella is not yet 18. So creepy 100 year old Edward is getting his creep on with underage Bella. There is no way around it this is creepy. Even if he wasn’t sitting there watching her sleep at night, even if he wasn’t constantly entertaining the notion of devouring her yummy smelling blood, he’s old enough to be her gorgeous great-great grandfather. How is this ok? Maybe if he was 82 and she was 24 I could see it. I mean what’s 58 years between lovers. However, when she’s too young to vote and he remembers the good ol’ days before women were legally allowed to vote I think we have reached a place we can label disturbing.
After the first book I was sufficiently creeped out enough to stop. I’m sad to say I’ll never know what happens in the second book when a new love interest emerges. Yes he happens to be a magical, Indian, werewolf, but why would that seem strange. Erica, however, is more dedicated than I and she pushed through reading all four in the series.
In defense of Book 1 Erica liked it. She liked it so much in fact that she defended Book 2 and 3 even though the story—defying all odds—gets worse after Book 1. It was the fourth book that did it for Erica. They say you have to hit rock bottom sometimes before you can admit the truth. Well in terms of the literature, Stephenie Meyer’s fourth book in the series, Breaking Dawn, rests comfortably in that place. I’m happy that Erica was able to admit now that Books 2 and 3 = crap. (A suspicion that I was confident enough in that I did not have to read those books to verify it.) I’m sad though because the book was so bad that Erica has sworn off all books for the time being. The memory of how bad a book can truly be is just too painful—the wounds too fresh. On the up side, she has already delivered to me one Christmas request. This Christmas, when the Tallahassee weather turns slightly cold, we will be having a small bonfire thanks to the fire-creating properties of Stephenie Meyer’s diligent labor. I’m glad to know that crap is indeed flammable and that we will be doing our part to rid the world of one little piece of evil.
